拿 (Na) and 發 (Fa)

拿 (Na) and 發 (Fa) 

In Tai Chi Push Hands (推手), the relationship between 拿 (Na) and 發 (Fa) is fundamental to controlling and issuing force. Let’s explore the theories behind Na (拿) and Fa (發) and how they work together.

---

1. What is 拿 (Na)?

拿 means to seize, control, or connect to the opponent without excessive force.

• It’s like picking up a handbag by the handle—you don’t squeeze too hard or let it slip.
• You establish a firm yet relaxed grip (粘黏) so that you can lead the opponent’s force in different directions.
• 拿 is often used before 發 (Fa) to position the opponent into a vulnerable structure.

Key principles of 拿:

柔 (Softness) – You must connect without using brute strength.

粘 (Adhesion) – Maintain continuous contact, sticking to their movement.

引 (Leading) – Guide their force rather than resisting directly.

Three Classical Na Techniques:

1. 引進 (Yin Jin) – Leading their energy forward or off-balance.
2. 牽動 (Qian Dong) – Slightly pulling or redirecting their movement.
3. 制約 (Zhi Yue) – Controlling their joints or structure subtly.

Example:

When your opponent pushes, instead of resisting, you lightly adhere (拿) and lead their force into emptiness before countering.

---

2. What is 發 (Fa)?

發勁 (Fa Jin) means to release or issue explosive force.

• After establishing 拿 (Na), you can release power (Jin 勁) at the right moment.
• 發 is not just about pushing—it’s about releasing stored energy efficiently.
• Proper 發 does not rely on muscular strength but on relaxed elasticity (彈勁).

Key principles of 發:

鬆 (Relaxation) – Tension blocks energy release; relaxation allows stored force to release naturally.

彈 (Elasticity) – Power is stored like a bowstring and suddenly released.

整 (Wholeness) – Power must come from the whole body, not just the arms.

Example:

After using 拿 (Na) to lead your opponent off balance, you release force (發) by expanding from the ground up, sending them flying.

---

3. The Relationship Between 拿 and 發

🔹 拿 is preparation, 發 is execution.

🔹 拿 establishes control, 發 capitalizes on it.

🔹 Without 拿, 發 is just brute force. Without 發, 拿 is incomplete.

Analogy: Holding and Releasing a Bow

• 拿 (Na) is like pulling back the bowstring and aiming.
• 發 (Fa) is like releasing the arrow with explosive precision.

If you 发 (Fa) without a good 拿 (Na), it’s like shooting without aiming.

If you 拿 (Na) but never 发 (Fa), it’s like holding a bowstring forever without releasing.

---

4. How to Train 拿與發 in Push Hands

🔹 Step 1: Practice 拿 (Na) without using brute force.

• Exercise: Hold your partner’s wrist like a handbag—firm but relaxed.
• Maintain contact without squeezing and feel their movement.

🔹 Step 2: Learn to redirect their force.

• Exercise: When they push, lead them slightly off balance before countering.

🔹 Step 3: Combine 拿 and 發 seamlessly.

• Exercise: Use 拿 to pull their weight onto one leg, then 发 by releasing stored energy from the ground.

---

5. Advanced Theories:

1) Borrowing Force (借力)

• 拿 is about borrowing the opponent’s momentum and turning it against them.
• If they push hard, 拿 absorbs and redirects it before 發 releases the energy.

2) Yin-Yang Transformation (陰陽轉換)

• 拿 (Na) is Yin (soft, receiving).
• 發 (Fa) is Yang (explosive, issuing).
• Mastery of Tai Chi Push Hands means seamlessly switching between Yin (拿) and Yang (發).

---

Conclusion:

1. 拿 (Na) allows you to control and connect, setting up the perfect opportunity for 發 (Fa).
2. 發 (Fa) is the final execution, where stored force is released explosively.

3. The analogy of pulling a blade of grass to describe the principles of na (拿 - grasping/controlling) and fa (發 - issuing/releasing) in martial arts, particularly in the context of grappling or chin na, is quite insightful. Let's break down the analogy and explore the underlying theories.

   Restated Description:

   The analogy suggests that effectively controlling and uprooting an opponent is similar to pulling a blade of grass. A forceful, direct pull on the leaf (analogous to grabbing an opponent's arm without connection) will likely result in the leaf (the arm) breaking or the grip slipping. Instead, the correct approach involves a softer, more yielding initial contact, akin to gently grasping the leaf. The crucial step is then applying a focused, even force that penetrates down to the root of the grass (analogous to connecting through the opponent's body to their feet). This "root connection" allows for a more effective and complete "uprooting" (controlling and destabilizing the opponent). Thus, pulling an opponent shouldn't be just about grabbing their arm; the arm is merely a conduit. The goal is to connect the force through the arm to the opponent's entire structure, ultimately affecting their balance and stability from the ground up.

   Theory Exploration:

   This analogy touches upon several key principles in martial arts, particularly those emphasizing internal power and leverage:

   1. Jin (勁 - Power/Force): The concept of jin is central here. It's not just brute strength, but rather a refined, coordinated force that originates from the ground, travels through the body, and is expressed through the point of contact. The grass analogy highlights the difference between li (力 - raw physical strength) and jin. Pulling the grass with li is like yanking the leaf; it's superficial and ineffective. Using jin is like the controlled, focused pull that reaches the root.

   2. Song (鬆 - Relaxation/Looseness): The initial "softness" in grasping the leaf (and the opponent's arm) is crucial. This relates to the principle of song. Relaxation allows for better force transmission and prevents rigidity, which can hinder the flow of jin. A tense grip will likely break, just as a tense body will be less effective at generating and transmitting power.

   3. Zheng (整 - Alignment/Unity): The connection to the "root" emphasizes the importance of whole-body alignment. Zheng refers to the coordinated movement of the body as a single unit. This is how the force generated from the ground can travel efficiently through the legs, torso, and arms to the point of contact. Without this connection, the pull will be weak and ineffective, like trying to pull the grass with just your fingertips.

   4. Li (力 - Leverage/Force): While li has already been defined as raw physical strength, it is also important to consider the concept of leverage. By connecting to the opponent's root (their center of gravity and base of support), you gain significant leverage. You're not just pulling on an arm; you're manipulating their entire structure, making it much easier to destabilize and control them.

   5. Fa Jing (發勁 - Issuing Force): The final "click" or "uprooting" action corresponds to fa jing. This is the explosive release of the accumulated and focused force. It's not just a sudden jerk, but rather the culmination of the proper alignment, relaxation, and connection, resulting in a powerful and efficient transfer of energy.

   In essence, the grass-pulling analogy illustrates the principles of using whole-body power, proper alignment, relaxation, and leverage to effectively control and manipulate an opponent, rather than relying on brute strength alone. It emphasizes the importance of connection and the flow of force through the body to achieve a more complete and effective outcome.

4. Together, they create effortless power—soft yet unstoppable.