Yan's 37 Form Ward off and Sit Back

Yan's 37 Form Ward off and Sit Back

The weight distribution and posture mechanics in Tai Chi, especially during the Peng (ward-off) posture, are key to maintaining balance, structure, and the ability to neutralize or issue force. Let's address each part of your question systematically:

---

1. Weight Distribution

• The guideline of 70% in the back leg and 30% in the front leg when starting, and 70% in the front leg and 30% in the back leg when finishing, is reasonable.
• Theories behind it:
  • Stability and Rooting (根): The initial weight distribution helps root the back leg, allowing for balance and readiness to respond to incoming force without overcommitting.
  • Dynamic Mobility: Transitioning to 70% on the front leg during the finishing phase maintains rootedness while enabling forward intent and power issuance (發勁, Fā Jìn).
  • Avoiding Overcommitment: Staying within this range (not exceeding 70%-30%) ensures mobility and prevents becoming "double-weighted" (雙重, Shuāng Zhòng), a principle flaw in Tai Chi.

---

2. Lower Arm Not Parallel to the Ground

• During Peng, the lower arm can be parallel to the ground.
• This positioning depends on the height of the opponent's incoming force and the need to maintain a rounded and connected structure (圓, Yuán).
• The arm's angle should adapt slightly to harmonize with the force's direction while maintaining the principle of a "curved bow" (弓形, Gōng Xíng).

---

3. Center of the Palm Facing the Chest or the Wrist?

• The center of the palm (勞宮穴, Láo Gōng Xuè) should generally face the centerline of your chest (中線, Zhōng Xiàn).
• The wrist (腕, Wàn) should remain relaxed and aligned but not aimed directly at the chest. Misalignment here could disrupt the internal connection (內勁, Nèi Jìn) between your hand and body.Your observations highlight key challenges and nuances in Tai Chi's ward-off posture (棚, Peng). Let’s break down your concerns and offer explanations and solutions:

  ---

  1. Difficulty Dropping the Elbow When the Lower Arm Is Parallel to the Ground

  • Why It's Hard:

    • When the lower arm is parallel to the ground, especially with the wrist and palm at nose height, the elbow naturally rises, creating tension. This rising elbow can disrupt the principle of relaxation (鬆, Sōng) and compromise your structure.
    • Dropping the elbow (垂肘, Chuí Zhǒu) is essential to connect the arm to the body's core and maintain an energetic flow from the Dantian (丹田). However, a parallel arm can lead to the elbow "floating" and breaking this connection.

  • Solution:

    • Instead of fixating on maintaining a perfectly parallel arm, adjust the angle slightly downward to allow the elbow to drop naturally. Even a slight tilt preserves the Peng Jin (棚勁) while keeping the elbow aligned and relaxed.
    • Think of "sinking the elbow" rather than dropping it forcefully, allowing gravity and relaxation to guide its position.

  ---

  2. The Wrist Appearing Stronger Than the Palm

  • Why the Wrist Feels Stronger:

    • When the palm and wrist are elevated to nose height, the wrist tends to lead the structure, creating an unintended wrist-centric focus. This diminishes the energy flow from the palm's center (勞宮穴, Láo Gōng Xuè) and disrupts the proper energetic alignment.
    • The wrist may feel mechanically stronger because it acts as a pivot point, but this strength lacks the subtle energy and structural support of the palm.

  • The Principle of Peng:

    • In Tai Chi, true strength comes from alignment. The palm, particularly the Láo Gōng point, is the energetic and structural focus, not the wrist. If the wrist leads, the connection to the core weakens, and the ward-off becomes "local" rather than whole-body.

  • Solution:

    • Lower the palm slightly (to about chin height) while maintaining the structure of the arm. This adjustment ensures that the palm—not the wrist—becomes the focal point of energy issuance and reception.
    • Imagine projecting energy outward from the Láo Gōng point, creating a sense of expansiveness, while keeping the wrist relaxed and aligned.

  ---

  3. Balancing Power and Energy Flow in the Ward-Off

  To integrate these adjustments while maintaining effective ward-off energy, follow these principles:

  • Palm as the Primary Tool:

    • Focus on projecting energy from the Láo Gōng point and not relying on the wrist’s mechanical strength. Think of the palm as the extension of the body's internal power (內勁, Nèi Jìn).
    • Keep the fingers naturally extended and slightly separated, maintaining a sense of liveliness in the hand.

  • Maintain a Slight Curve:

    • The arm should not be stiffly parallel to the ground. Instead, it should form a gentle curve like an archery bow (弓形, Gōng Xíng), with the elbow sinking naturally to connect to the body's structure.

  • Whole-Body Integration:

    • Ensure the power comes from the ground up, passing through the legs, waist, and back, and finally expressing through the arm and palm. This integration makes the palm stronger than the wrist in application.

  ---

  Visualization Exercise for Alignment

  1. Stand in the ward-off posture with the palm at chin height and slightly angled.
  2. Imagine the energy flowing from the back foot, through the Dantian, and spiraling outward to the Láo Gōng point.
  3. Feel the elbow sink naturally as part of this flow, keeping the wrist relaxed and the palm alive.

  By maintaining these adjustments, you will balance structural strength and energetic flow, enabling an effective and relaxed ward-off posture.

---

4. Space Between the Arm and the Body (Including Armpit)

• Yes, there should always be a space maintained:
  • Arm: Keep a slight distance from the torso to avoid "collapsing the frame" (架子塌, Jià Zi Tā). This ensures the arm structure remains strong and can absorb or issue energy effectively.
  • Armpit (腋, Yè): Maintain an "egg-sized" space under the armpit to preserve the roundness and elasticity of the posture. Collapsing this space hinders energy flow and weakens the Peng Jin (棚勁).

---

Summary of Key Principles

1. Weight Transition: Balanced progression ensures root stability and mobility.
2. Arm Parallelism: Adjust the lower arm's angle based on energy flow and opponent's force.
3. Palm Center Alignment: Keep Láo Gōng facing the chest for structural and energetic connection.
4. Maintain Space: Allow space between arm and body for a strong, adaptable frame.

These practices align with Tai Chi's core principles of relaxation (鬆, Sōng), connection (連, Lián), and dynamic balance (平衡, Píng Héng).

The angle of the back leg

The angle of the back leg during ward-off (棚, Peng) in Tai Chi plays a crucial role in maintaining stability, balance, and the ability to transfer energy effectively. Let’s analyze the various angles and their implications, along with the optimal position when sitting back.

---

1. Back Leg Angle During Ward-Off

• Common Recommendations:

  • 30 degrees to the front: This position offers more forward alignment and may feel natural for direct movement.
  • 45 degrees to the front: This is a classic Tai Chi stance that balances stability and mobility.
  • Aligned fully forward: Moving toward the front maximizes directional intent but may reduce lateral stability.

• Analysis of Each Angle:

  • 30 Degrees:
    • Provides good forward intent (進步, Jìn Bù) and efficient energy transfer to the front foot.
    • However, it reduces lateral stability, making it harder to handle side forces (橫力, Héng Lì).
  • 45 Degrees:
    • Offers a balanced compromise between stability and mobility.
    • Aligns the rear leg diagonally, maintaining the ability to pivot and redirect energy while preserving a rooted connection to the ground (根, Gēn).
  • Fully Forward:
    • Facilitates the most efficient forward movement.
    • However, this alignment can compromise your ability to absorb or deflect force coming from the side or rear, risking imbalance.

• Best Choice:

  • 45 degrees is generally the most efficient and versatile for the back leg during ward-off:
    • It balances stability, mobility, and the ability to adapt to multidirectional forces.
    • It aligns the body’s structure while keeping the kua (hips, 胯, Kuà) open, allowing seamless energy transfer.

---

2. Back Leg Angle When Sitting Back

• When sitting back, the degree of the back leg depends on maintaining structure while being ready to redirect force:
  • Optimal Angle: Around 45 to 60 degrees to the front.
    • Why?: This range allows the kua to stay open, which is crucial for absorbing and redirecting incoming energy.
    • A steeper angle (closer to 60 degrees) increases the range of defensive mobility and readiness for lateral movement.
  • Avoid aligning the back foot directly sideways (90 degrees), as this risks collapsing the structure and limiting forward or rotational movements.

---

Theories Behind Leg Angles

• Rooting and Stability (根, Gēn): The back leg acts as the primary anchor. Angling it appropriately prevents the center of gravity from becoming unstable.
• Energy Flow (氣, Qì): The leg angles must align with the path of energy flow to maintain connectedness from the feet to the hands. Improper angles can disrupt this flow, making movements less effective.
• Mobility and Adaptability: The back leg angle should allow seamless weight shifts and easy redirection of force.

---

Conclusion

1. Back Leg Angle During Ward-Off:

   • 45 degrees to the front offers the best balance between stability, mobility, and energy transfer.
   • Adjust slightly (closer to 30 degrees or steeper to 60 degrees) based on personal body mechanics or opponent’s position.

2. Back Leg Angle When Sitting Back:

   • Maintain around 45-60 degrees to preserve structure and readiness to deflect or issue force.

3. Key Reminder:

   • Always keep the kua open and the weight properly distributed. The rear foot should remain rooted and aligned with the overall intent of your posture. Avoid locking the knee or collapsing the ankle, as this disrupts the energy flow and compromises the integrity of your movement.Your questions touch on key principles in Tai Chi, focusing on the sequence of weight shifts, structural alignment, and kua-shoulder relationships during ward-off and turning. Here's a detailed breakdown with theories and explanations.

     ---

     1. Should the Hind Leg Be Empty (No Weight) or Maintain 30% Weight During Turning?

     Theories Behind Each Approach

     1. Hind Leg Turns First and Becomes Empty (No Weight)

        • Advantages:

          • Turning the hind leg first facilitates a smoother pivot, as the weight shifts away from the pivoting foot.
          • This approach emphasizes agility and prepares the body to issue force forward without resistance from the rear leg.
          • It avoids dragging the foot, which could disrupt balance or create unnecessary resistance.

        • Disadvantages:

          • With no weight on the hind leg, you risk losing the rear connection to the ground (根, Gēn) and reducing overall stability.
          • This method can lead to an overemphasis on forward intent (進步, Jìn Bù) while neglecting the role of the hind leg in maintaining a rooted structure.

     2. Hind Leg Maintains 30% Weight to Connect to the Ground

        • Advantages:

          • Maintaining 30% weight on the hind leg ensures that you remain connected to the ground through both legs. This enhances your stability and ability to absorb and redirect force.
          • It aligns with the principle of dual-weightedness avoidance (不雙重, Bù Shuāng Zhòng)—keeping a dynamic balance where neither leg is completely empty or overloaded.
          • This method creates a sense of "whole-body power" (整體勁, Zhěng Tǐ Jìn), integrating the legs, waist, and hands for issuing energy.

        • Disadvantages:

          • Turning may feel slower or more constrained if the hind leg bears too much weight, especially if the kua (hips, 胯) are not properly open.
          • Requires precise control to prevent the hind leg from resisting the forward energy flow.

     ---

     Which Is Better?

     • Best Approach: Maintain 30% weight on the hind leg during turning.

       • This ensures a strong connection to the ground while allowing for smooth, controlled movement.
       • The hind leg remains engaged but light enough to pivot easily, combining stability with agility.

     • Why Not Fully Empty the Hind Leg?

       • If the hind leg is completely empty, you may lose structural integrity and the ability to "borrow force" from the ground for issuing or redirecting energy.
       • Tai Chi emphasizes maintaining a dynamic balance and continuous connection to the earth, even during transitions.

     ---

     2. Should the Kua and Shoulder Points Form a Rectangle That Maintains Its Shape?

     Understanding the Rectangle Concept

     • The idea is that the two kua points (hips) and two shoulder points form a rectangle. During movements like ward-off and turning, this rectangle should ideally maintain its proportional shape and alignment.

     Theories Supporting This Concept

     1. Structural Integrity:

        • Maintaining the rectangle ensures that the body moves as a single, unified structure (整體, Zhěng Tǐ).
        • If the rectangle deforms, it can indicate misalignment or a break in the connection between the upper and lower body.

     2. Energy Flow:

        • A stable rectangle supports smooth energy transfer from the ground through the kua to the shoulders and hands.
        • Deforming the rectangle may cause energy "leakage" or disrupt the flow of Jin (勁).

     3. Balance and Coordination:

        • A consistent rectangle helps maintain proper weight distribution and coordination during transitions, reducing the risk of losing balance.

     ---

     Challenges to Maintaining a Rectangle

     • While maintaining the rectangle is a useful guideline, some adjustments are natural and necessary:
       • The rectangle may slightly twist or tilt depending on the movement, especially during spiraling or rotational actions.
       • For example, the front kua may advance slightly during forward movement, causing a subtle diagonal shift in the rectangle.

     Best Practice

     • Maintain the Rectangle as a Reference, but allow for subtle adjustments:
       • Think of the rectangle as a "dynamic frame" rather than a rigid shape.
       • Focus on maintaining the connection between the kua and shoulders while allowing the rectangle to adjust naturally to the movement.

     ---

     Conclusion

     1. Hind Leg in Turning:

        • Maintain 30% weight on the hind leg during turning for optimal stability and ground connection. Fully emptying the leg risks losing structural integrity.

     2. Kua-Shoulder Rectangle:

        • The rectangle between the kua and shoulders serves as a valuable guideline for alignment and energy flow. While it should generally remain consistent, allow for natural adjustments during rotational movements to avoid rigidity.

     ---

     By focusing on these principles, you'll balance structure, flexibility, and energy flow, aligning with Tai Chi's core philosophy of dynamic balance and whole-body connection.